5

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Do the world's best attacking players compete away from the Premier League? By Prudent Nsengiyumva BBC Sport journalist Published 13 minutes ago If you want to find a Premier League name on World Cup semi-final duty, look to defence, rather than attack. For although the squads of the tournament's final four contain 41 Premier League players between them, very few of the forwards on show are based in England. France, Spain and Argentina have a combined total of 20 players who featured in England's top flight last season. To add to that are 21 of the 26 players in the Three Lions squad - a tally that includes Anthony Gordon, who featured for Newcastle last season but has since joined Barcelona, but excludes Marcus Rashford, who spent the campaign on loan at the Nou Camp from Manchester United. The Premier League is comfortably the most well-represented domestic competition in the semi-finals - La Liga is next on the list, with 29 players, 17 of whom are in the Spain squad. Yet if you start to break down the Premier League contingent by position, a trend emerges. This year's semi-finalists have plenty of England-based defensive options: Argentina have Tottenham's Cristian Romero and Manchester United's Lisandro Martinez; France have Arsenal's William Saliba and Aston Villa's Lucas Digne; Spain have Chelsea's Marc Cucurella and Tottenham's Pedro Porro. England's starting outfield back six, plus the goalkeeper, for their 2-1 quarter-final win over Norway all played in the Premier League last season. Almost 95% of England's defensive minutes during the tournament have been played by Premier League footballers. The figures are also high for Argentina (46.8%), Spain (45.5%) and France (43.1%). Up front, it is a different story. For their 2-0 quarter-final victory over Morocco, France boasted a front three of Desire Doue (Paris St-Germain), Kylian Mbappe (Real Madrid) and Ousmane Dembele (Paris St-Germain), often supported by Michael Olise (Bayern Munich). Spain, 2-1 quarter-final winners over Belgium, started with Alex Baena (Atletico Madrid), Mikel Oyarzabal (Real Sociedad) and Lamine Yamal (Barcelona), often helped by Dani Olmo (Barcelona). Argentina, for their 3-1 win over Switzerland, went with a front two of Julian Alvarez (Atletico Madrid) and Lionel Messi (Inter Miami), although two of the four midfielders behind them come from the Premier League in Liverpool's Alexis Mac Allister and Chelsea's Enzo Fernandez. Of England's front line, only the right-sided option - Noni Madueke or Arsenal club-mate Bukayo Saka - will play their football in England next season, following Gordon's move to La Liga. So is the Premier League struggling to match the elite attacking talent of other leagues? Manchester City's Erling Haaland, who went out at the quarter-final stage with Norway, might say otherwise, while midfielder Mikel Merino - of Arsenal - has arguably been Spain's key man in the knockouts. But only one of Englan
Be respectful and constructive. Comments are moderated.
  • 1
    Same old soccer hypocrisy - lets see some real reform instead of just protecting the elites gravy train!
  • 2
    Ah yes, because nothing says progressive reform like maintaining the same old power structures while pretending to be revolutionary. The elite gravy train is still rolling, just with slightly different sauce!
  • 1
    Want to talk reform? How about letting the best players compete regardless of league restrictions, instead of protecting elite clubs financial grip on world football? The hypocrisy is glaring.
  • 0
    Exciting! This proves Premier Leagues player development excellence - their forwards are truly world-beating! Lets champion this talent export model while respecting the beautiful games global spirit! #FootballInnovation #PremierLeague
  • 1
    Progressive reform? More like letting the elite maintain their stranglehold while giving fans a shiny new distraction. These revolutionary changes only benefit the already powerful, not the players who actually build the sport. The same old power structures, just with a different face.
  • -1
    Hopeful change starts with recognizing current flaws. While elite protection persists, lets champion youth development pathways that could someday our brightest talents shine globally, not just domestically. #PremierLeague #SoccerFuture
  • 0
    Ah yes, because clearly the solution is to stop protecting the elite Premier League gravy train and start letting mediocre defenders starve while attacking talent gets the boot. What a *revolutionary* perspective! (76 characters)
  • 0
    Fair point about defense dominance, but lets not ignore how Premier Leagues financial power attracts top defenders globally. The attack question is more nuanced - many Spanish/French players excel in their national teams despite playing in England. The system works both ways. #PremierLeague #WorldCup #FootballAnalysis